I have just listened to Alyssa host of The Big Red Podcast’s review of the new TV pilot for the Dollhouse (Fox). I agree with Alyssa's comments wholeheartedly.
I watched with an intensity born from a love of Whedon's other series Firefly. I was on board if it was going to have a certain amount of eye candy, but the pilot was morally reprehensible.
I didn’t understand that Echo’s first “mission” was actually as a call girl until well into the second half, when one of her dumb memories made it clearer. This isn't the first televised play dealing with sex and currency, but the thing that twists this too far is the way the Stepford wives horror is presented. There is no loss of humanity, there is no consequence. There is no conscience depicted in the hero or elsewhere.
It’s a bad, bad, premise. But it is also stupid. If the Dollhouse business works so well, and their scruples are conditional, why don’t they become kidnappers and skip the pretense of any do-gooding? My wife asked me if at the end, the Dollhouse organization returned the ransom. And after considering it, I not only think they did not return the money, I don’t remember seeing them return the little girl. Maybe they flew her away in a helicopter and later made her into meat pies.
It had one decent (Whedon-esque) line at the beginning. “Ever try to clean a slate?” That is hardly enough to base a show upon.
Firefly fans would compare the character arc of River Tam and Echo. Their stories are inverse. River's brain is clumsily cut up by an evil organization. She struggles with the scars. Echo signs over her soul and joins an evil organization. She lives happily ever after.
Showing posts with label Big Red Podcast. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Big Red Podcast. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
Wednesday, September 17, 2008
Big Red Wrong Again?
I am beginning to understand that it is the way The Big Red Podcast reviews TV that is irritating, not their views. Here is a recent comment I made on their forum.
I do value The Big Red Podcast’s opinion. They said True Blood was boring and I believe them. I was a fan of Six Feet Under for a few seasons. True Blood is a show by the same creator, but I have heard the man out promoting True Blood and I don't know, maybe he said everything he had to in the earlier series.
You are infuriating! You weave the positive comments in so thoroughly with the rhythmic stream of BS—I guess that’s entertainment.
The key to the Fringe pilot is the set up of a dance between mad scientists. All else is secondary. But of that secondary material you found:
The pilot was plot heavy/“the seams are showing”
There was a lot of running around
There wasn’t much character development
The young leads had no chemistry
You didn’t get anything wrong you just made TV conventions seem like mistakes. It is a pilot. It is going to introduce characters. It is going to give them motivations. It is going to develop settings. You seem to ignore that the medium is fast. Would you want the pilot to explain the reasons why the Evil Dynamics Incorporated character has that incredibly weird office space? That would really be fascinating TV. Her choice of decorator, how she found them in the yellowpages.
Deeps made a spot-on comment when he said the young female actress did a lot with expression. Yes. That was amazing. She is cautiously in love. She wants to be apart of a team that doesn’t trust her. She is reluctant to use the power of her office. She is willing to bend her personal code for love…I could go on and on. It isn’t that they didn’t give her character much to do. They gave her face way too much to do, and the actress handled the job and still made it restrained and real. Even when the action is ridiculous, the rest of her performance sells it.
Why would there be chemistry between the young lead characters? She is insanely committed to someone else. By the end of the pilot she should be in shock. The mad scientist’s son starts out as her unwilling instrument. He is wrapped up in daddy issues.
It might be a stronger criticism to mention that the show ends like a TV pilot. Everyone decides to stay together and work with a cow in the corner. I believe the ending was quite badly done. Seams indeed, the sewing machine falls off the table.
I do value The Big Red Podcast’s opinion. They said True Blood was boring and I believe them. I was a fan of Six Feet Under for a few seasons. True Blood is a show by the same creator, but I have heard the man out promoting True Blood and I don't know, maybe he said everything he had to in the earlier series.
Tuesday, April 8, 2008
Big Red Podcast
I just found the Big Red Podcast. This is a pop culture show comprised of TV reviews with a smattering of literature. The audio is very good and the talking heads take turns and control their interactions well. I haven't heard a single earsplitting outburst. They make allusion to a breakfast meeting where the group has already hashed out what they might say and where the emotional reactions, full of swearing and spitting of egg, are discreetly kept away from my tender ears. Thank you.
One thing you might want to say to these people is “put the TiVo down.” They seem to be consuming way more TV than is necessary. But this works to the listener's advantage...at least in the short term. I have listened to four episodes and these have either confirmed a presumption about certain on-going series or made me excited to netflix a new series that I was unaware of. In short, the Big Red Podcast is a winner. I will return to one of the criticisms the Big Red Podcast made last year about Madmen. This would bear upon one of my past blog entries. I will comment back in that blog 7/23/07.
Some podcast losers. (evil snicker)
In the same arena, but not in the same league are “Hey, want to watch a movie?” podcast and “Destroy All Media” Show. I have been looking for new shows at Podcast Pickle instead of Podcast Alley. I have found hidden gems at Pickle before. However these two did not fall into that category.
First of all the sound of Want to Watch a Movie? is atrocious. When I explain the nature of the show one can understand why. This show creates commentary tracks meant to accompany favorite movies. The first minutes are an explanation of this, then an introduction of the cast and finally a countdown to sync your pod-cast up with the movie. The Hollywood Saloon did this once with much higher production values. Please refer back to my November 2007 blog. The key problem for Want to Watch a Movie? is the group commenting on the film seem to be linked via skype. Skype seems to be a highly compressed scheme for phoning through your computer. I've heard call-ins to podcasts from listeners using a skype connection and the hosts regularly hang up on them. This tells you how poor the sound quality can be, because programs recorded live are very desirous of a decent call in from a listener. So now imagine a show based entirely on this type of sound. Additionally, this show introduces a huge number of people who, in theory, would be adding comments. It would be far too many to keep tabs on if they actually all did have comments, but there are frequent dead silences which make you want to check if your headphones came unplugged, but no, it is just where (10?) people have nothing to say. To be fair, I didn't listen while I was synced. But still...Skip this show, it is still in hobby mode. It isn't that the comments for the movies aren't funny and intelligent, but I found it not worth the trouble given the movie selections.
Better is Destroy All Media, but not by any great margin. Three guys discuss tv and movies in this podcast. One of these men is a huge nerd. Star Trek knowledge, a full-blown goober. This makes the other two speakers cool in proximity, and there is a friendly awareness of this dynamic. The sound quality here is not so great. The nerd is heard most clearly, with his hipper peanut-gallery off mic or at some greater distance (besides a degree of hipper style). This is the opposite arrangement for optimum enjoyment. You want a know-it-all to chime in with some trivia occasionally, not run the show. Also if you have a Cliff Claven happening, you want to double-check his info. Nerdman went off on a tangent about the director Coen Brothers when he actually meant the director Wawkowski Brothers. Ooops! My inner nerd is showing.
Still, You might want to take a chance on this show. It could be made better with the a couple more mics and a bit more structure.
One thing you might want to say to these people is “put the TiVo down.” They seem to be consuming way more TV than is necessary. But this works to the listener's advantage...at least in the short term. I have listened to four episodes and these have either confirmed a presumption about certain on-going series or made me excited to netflix a new series that I was unaware of. In short, the Big Red Podcast is a winner. I will return to one of the criticisms the Big Red Podcast made last year about Madmen. This would bear upon one of my past blog entries. I will comment back in that blog 7/23/07.
Some podcast losers. (evil snicker)
In the same arena, but not in the same league are “Hey, want to watch a movie?” podcast and “Destroy All Media” Show. I have been looking for new shows at Podcast Pickle instead of Podcast Alley. I have found hidden gems at Pickle before. However these two did not fall into that category.
First of all the sound of Want to Watch a Movie? is atrocious. When I explain the nature of the show one can understand why. This show creates commentary tracks meant to accompany favorite movies. The first minutes are an explanation of this, then an introduction of the cast and finally a countdown to sync your pod-cast up with the movie. The Hollywood Saloon did this once with much higher production values. Please refer back to my November 2007 blog. The key problem for Want to Watch a Movie? is the group commenting on the film seem to be linked via skype. Skype seems to be a highly compressed scheme for phoning through your computer. I've heard call-ins to podcasts from listeners using a skype connection and the hosts regularly hang up on them. This tells you how poor the sound quality can be, because programs recorded live are very desirous of a decent call in from a listener. So now imagine a show based entirely on this type of sound. Additionally, this show introduces a huge number of people who, in theory, would be adding comments. It would be far too many to keep tabs on if they actually all did have comments, but there are frequent dead silences which make you want to check if your headphones came unplugged, but no, it is just where (10?) people have nothing to say. To be fair, I didn't listen while I was synced. But still...Skip this show, it is still in hobby mode. It isn't that the comments for the movies aren't funny and intelligent, but I found it not worth the trouble given the movie selections.
Better is Destroy All Media, but not by any great margin. Three guys discuss tv and movies in this podcast. One of these men is a huge nerd. Star Trek knowledge, a full-blown goober. This makes the other two speakers cool in proximity, and there is a friendly awareness of this dynamic. The sound quality here is not so great. The nerd is heard most clearly, with his hipper peanut-gallery off mic or at some greater distance (besides a degree of hipper style). This is the opposite arrangement for optimum enjoyment. You want a know-it-all to chime in with some trivia occasionally, not run the show. Also if you have a Cliff Claven happening, you want to double-check his info. Nerdman went off on a tangent about the director Coen Brothers when he actually meant the director Wawkowski Brothers. Ooops! My inner nerd is showing.
Still, You might want to take a chance on this show. It could be made better with the a couple more mics and a bit more structure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)